Denver, Colorado — A Colorado jury has convicted a man of first-degree murder in the 2016 death of his girlfriend aboard an Amtrak train, closing a case that took seven years to reach trial after initial autopsy findings failed to determine how the young mother died.
Prosecutors said Angelo Valentino Mantych, 43, strangled 28-year-old Marina Placensia during an overnight train ride from Wisconsin to Denver as the couple’s four children slept just feet away. The verdict was returned Friday after jurors deliberated for about five hours. Mantych is scheduled to be sentenced on January 9.
Death discovered at Denver Union Station
According to court records and statements from the Denver District Attorney’s Office, Placensia was found unresponsive when the train arrived at Denver Union Station in late August 2016. Emergency responders attempted life-saving measures, but she was pronounced dead at the scene.
Mantych told investigators that he tried to wake her shortly before arrival and believed she was simply a heavy sleeper. He claimed he realized something was wrong only minutes before the train stopped and asked for help.
“Your Affiant observed that Mantych appeared to be upset, crying and vomited several times,” investigators noted at the time.
No passengers initially reported seeing a disturbance on the train, and early medical examinations could not conclusively determine a cause of death, allowing the case to remain unresolved for years.
Prosecutors say victim planned to leave abusive relationship
During trial, prosecutors presented evidence showing Placensia had planned to leave Mantych once they reached Denver, where family members were waiting to support her.
Assistant District Attorney Lara Mullin told jurors that Mantych understood the move marked the end of his control over Placensia.
“He knows what is waiting at that train station is a collection of family members who are going to make sure he doesn’t go home with Marina and the boys,” Mullin said. “Because things were at a breaking point and people knew it.”
Prosecutors argued that Mantych killed Placensia in the middle of the night, using suffocation and pressure to her face, while their children slept nearby and other passengers remained unaware.
Years-long investigation reveals pattern of abuse
Although no immediate cause of death was determined in 2016, investigators later uncovered extensive evidence of long-term domestic abuse.
A renewed forensic review in May concluded that Placensia died from asphyxia due to suffocation, with injuries consistent with pressure to the nose and mouth.
“Ms. Placensia exhibits multiple areas of oral and perioral trauma consistent with asphyxia from suffocation,” a forensic doctor wrote. “The manner of death is homicide.”
Autopsy findings documented bruising across her face, mouth, thighs, calves, abdomen, and upper body, along with fractured ribs. Prosecutors said Mantych repeatedly offered shifting explanations for the injuries, blaming moving accidents, doors striking her, and even one of the children.
Witnesses describe escalating violence before the move
Multiple witnesses testified about a violent relationship in the months and years leading up to Placensia’s death. Neighbors described frequent fights and said Mantych had physically and emotionally abused both Placensia and the children.
One neighbor told investigators that Mantych beat Placensia the day before the family left Wisconsin. Others reported seeing her wear sweaters and sunglasses in summer to conceal injuries.
During the move, witnesses said Mantych slapped, punched, grabbed her neck, pulled her hair, and shouted degrading insults while ordering her and the children to move faster.
In one chilling allegation, a witness said Mantych once held a baby over a balcony and threatened Placensia to comply with his demands.
Children also subjected to abuse, testimony shows
Testimony also detailed alleged abuse directed at the children. Witnesses recalled hearing one child plead, “Please stop, it hurts,” to which Mantych allegedly responded with threats and insults.
School officials and social services later reported concerns about the children arriving at school in dirty clothes and smelling of urine, prompting further scrutiny after Placensia’s death.
Prosecutors argued that fear and intimidation kept the children silent, allowing the abuse to continue largely unchecked.
Breakthrough leads to charges after seven years
For years, the lack of a definitive medical conclusion stalled the case. That changed after renewed forensic analysis and witness cooperation helped prosecutors build a timeline pointing to homicide rather than natural causes.
Mantych was eventually charged, bringing long-awaited accountability in a case that had haunted investigators and Placensia’s family.
Jurors ultimately agreed with the prosecution’s argument that Mantych murdered Placensia to prevent her escape from the relationship.
Read Also: Georgia Woman Hospitalized After Corrosive Chemical Attack During Evening Walk Near Forsyth Park
Sentencing and broader implications
Mantych now faces life imprisonment when he is sentenced next month. The case highlights the challenges of prosecuting domestic violence deaths when abuse occurs behind closed doors — or, in this case, aboard a moving train.
Advocates say the verdict underscores the importance of revisiting unresolved deaths when new forensic techniques and testimony emerge.
Placensia’s death, prosecutors said, was not sudden or inexplicable, but the culmination of years of escalating violence.
What lessons should authorities and communities take from cases where domestic abuse remains hidden for so long? Share your thoughts in the comments.
