Middle Island, N.Y. – A group of armed teenagers allegedly lured a 17-year-old Long Island resident with the promise of buying high-end merchandise he posted online, only to pull out guns and steal approximately $6,000 in goods, according to Suffolk County prosecutors.
The suspects include Isaac Brutus, 19, Aubre Vandunk, 18, and two unidentified minors aged 16 and 17, who orchestrated the scheme in what authorities are calling a planned bait-and-switch robbery.
Robbery Goes Awry at Middle Island Apartment Complex
Officials say the victim was contacted via social media, where he had advertised clothing for sale. The group arranged to meet the teen outside a Middle Island apartment complex on October 9 around 5 p.m.
According to prosecutors, what began as a routine transaction quickly escalated. Brutus allegedly attempted to steal the victim’s car, and the group brandished firearms before fleeing with the merchandise.
“Gunpoint robberies such as the crime alleged here will not be tolerated in Suffolk County,” said District Attorney Ray Tierney. “My office is committed to holding those who use guns to commit crimes fully accountable and to protecting the safety of Suffolk County residents.”
Suspects Tracked and Apprehended by Police
Authorities quickly located the group with the assistance of a police canine. Following a brief standoff, the suspects surrendered to law enforcement without further incident.
During the arrest, police recovered three loaded illegal handguns and a BB gun modified to resemble a real firearm, along with the stolen merchandise.
Charges and Court Proceedings
All four suspects face felony robbery charges and multiple weapons-related offenses, as per The Post.
Acting Supreme Court Justice Karen Kerr set $250,000 cash bail or partially secured bonds up to $2.5 million for each of the accused. Court schedules for the suspects are as follows:
- 16-year-old minor: due back in court today
- Aubre Vandunk, 18, and the 17-year-old minor: return on December 1
- Isaac Brutus, 19: scheduled for December 8
Prosecutors emphasized the severity of the case, noting that armed robberies involving minors and firearms are treated with the highest priority in Suffolk County.
Community and Social Media Safety Concerns
The incident highlights the risks of conducting private sales through social media, especially for minors and young adults. Authorities are urging residents to:
- Meet in public, well-lit areas
- Bring a friend or guardian
- Avoid confronting or negotiating with individuals who display suspicious or aggressive behavior
Police also remind the public that any incident involving firearms should be reported immediately to law enforcement to prevent escalation.
How can teens and young adults safely conduct online transactions without risking robbery or violence?
Share your experiences and tips in the comments below, and let us know how communities can keep residents safe from social media scams and armed thefts.
